The High Court in Belfast has dismissed John Cousins's judicial review challenge to a decision by Newry Mourne and Down District Council refusing his application for membership of Kilkeel Leisure Centre and imposing a further five-year exclusion from all indoor leisure sites in the council area. Mr Justice McLaughlin delivered judgment on 10 November 2026. The application was dismissed on all grounds.

The challenged decision was dated 12 March 2025. The court examined whether the council's process was procedurally fair, whether it breached a legitimate expectation of a meeting, and whether the exclusion was irrational. The council had previously excluded the applicant from its leisure facilities, including a five-year exclusion imposed in 2020 that was not appealed or challenged.

The court found that the council did not hold a meeting before the March 2025 decision and that this failed to meet procedural fairness standards at that stage. It also found that the March 2020 correspondence contained "a procedural commitment which was sufficiently clear and unambiguous" to create a legitimate expectation that the applicant would be offered a meeting before any future membership decision. The judge said this expectation was not fulfilled in March 2025.

However, the court concluded that the process as a whole was fair. In a pre-action response dated 6 November 2025, the council revoked the further five-year exclusion and replaced it with an interim exclusion pending a meeting and a new decision. A meeting took place on 4 December 2025 between the applicant, his advocate, and council officers including Safeguarding Officer Gary Scott. The court found that the meeting gave the applicant a fair opportunity to make his case for reinstatement. It stated that "the applicant was afforded a full and fair opportunity to make his case for re-instatement."

The court rejected additional arguments that the applicant should have received prior disclosure of the risk assessment and prior allegations, and that Mr Scott's involvement compromised independence. It noted that Mr Scott was not the decision-maker and that the council's pre-action response set out a summary of previous allegations. The judge said the risks were "perfectly obvious" to the applicant. The court also found the rationality challenge unsustainable.

The court noted concerns about the applicant's duty of candour, describing his affidavit evidence as "grossly lacking in material detail", but did not decide whether that warranted summary dismissal because the case was resolved on the merits. It also held that there was a sufficient public law element for judicial review, despite private law aspects of the council-user relationship. The application was dismissed.