Finance Minister accuses Westminster of underfunding as Assembly backs Pension Schemes Bill
The Assembly’s main business on Tuesday 17 November was a statement from Finance Minister John O’Dowd on the Executive Budget and fair funding, followed by the accelerated passage and Second Stage of the Pension Schemes Bill, a Committee for Education debate on special educational needs and Question Time with the Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs Minister.
O’Dowd told MLAs that the North was expected to be funded below 124% of assessed need in every year of the spending review and that around one third of the financial package on offer would be needed just to reach the level agreed by the Westminster government. He said Treasury’s own assessment showed underfunding in 2027-28 and 2028-29, and that comparable funding to Scotland would mean around £3.2 billion more a year, while comparable funding to Wales would mean around £1.5 billion more. He argued that the Executive did not have a Budget problem so much as a problem with Westminster’s failure to fund the region properly, saying: 'The Executive do not have a Budget problem as much as a problem with the persistent failure of Westminster Governments to fund this place properly or on a fair basis.'
He called for a fiscal framework including access to the National Wealth Fund, Housing Executive borrowing powers and consideration of fiscal devolution. He said his priority was a pay uplift for health workers, teachers, police, civil servants and other public-sector workers, and rejected suggestions that revenue raising alone could close the gap. He noted that raising an extra £100 million through the regional rate would require an 11% increase.
Opposition leader Matthew O’Toole called the statement 'a shambles and a disgrace' and said the Executive should set a Budget rather than blame London. O’Dowd accused O’Toole of speaking for the Secretary of State, Chris Bryant, and said he was 'defending the indefensible.' DUP members supported the call for fair funding but pressed the Minister on accountability, including a Northern Ireland Audit Office report on £5.1 million wasted on a botched MOT procurement contract and health capital overspends. The Minister said efficiency and fair funding were not an either/or choice.
The Assembly later agreed, with cross-community support, that the Pension Schemes Bill proceed by accelerated passage, and it also passed the Bill’s Second Stage. Communities Minister Gordon Lyons said the Bill would maintain parity with the Pension Schemes Act 2026 and introduce reforms on value for money, consolidation of small dormant pots, guided retirement, pension superfunds and pensions dashboards. He said the accelerated timetable was 'not ideal' but necessary to avoid divergence and disadvantage for savers here.
Committee for Communities Chairperson Colm Gildernew said the Committee had not had a Committee Stage and could not report a concluded view or stakeholder evidence on the Bill. He noted that members had held summer information sessions but that a 97-clause Bill would proceed without normal clause-by-clause scrutiny. Ulster Unionist MLA Andy Allen said his party would reluctantly support accelerated passage, while Alliance and SDLP members raised concerns about delegated powers, the £25 billion scale threshold and powers that could influence pension scheme investment. Lyons said safeguards would remain and that officials would be available to assist the Committee with secondary legislation.
In the Committee for Education debate, Chairperson Nick Mathison moved a motion noting the report on the strategic review of special educational needs and calling on the Education Minister to prioritise early intervention and stronger support for schools before any reduction in support ratios is considered. The report found significant systemic challenges, including specialist staffing shortages in the Irish-medium sector, and recommended a simpler reform agenda, an inclusive education policy, action on the placement crisis, a review of the SENCO role, guidance on restraint and seclusion, and closer Health and Education working. Mathison criticised the Education Minister’s absence from the debate, saying the issue affected many parents, teachers and pupils.
Sinn Féin’s Pat Sheehan said children with SEN in the Irish-medium sector were particularly disadvantaged by the lack of a workforce plan and criticised the use of a petition of concern to block workforce planning. The debate was suspended for Question Time and was due to resume later.
During Question Time, Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs Minister Andrew Muir said 65 eel fishers had received initial payments totalling £209,987 under the Lough Neagh eel fishery transition scheme. He said he was confident that a positive UK-EU sanitary and phytosanitary agreement would be announced at Friday’s summit, arguing that Brexit had made the UK poorer and that closer EU ties would benefit Northern Ireland. He also said Northern Ireland’s first climate action plan was overdue and had been with Executive colleagues since August, and he called for Executive agreement on designating inner Belfast Lough as a sensitive area for shellfish protection.
Muir faced questions on Lough Neagh blue-green algae, packaging regulation, household recycling and nature recovery. He said £49 million from the Shared Island Fund would support a catchment water quality programme and that his Department was progressing stronger regulation of sewage discharges. On climate policy, he defended carbon footprinting for farmers and rejected claims that climate action was ideology, saying it was based on science and evidence.
Earlier, Members’ statements covered a range of issues. DUP MLA Peter Martin called for a statutory public inquiry in the Republic of Ireland into the Omagh bombing and said he would write to the Taoiseach in support of the families’ request. Other statements highlighted fuel poverty, carers’ rights, threatening emails sent to schools, lung cancer screening, medical misogyny in access to surgical robots, end-of-life poverty and a King’s Award for Voluntary Service for Donaghadee Community Development Association.
Question Time with the Executive Office began with deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly extending condolences to Lord Morrow and his family following the deaths of his daughter and wife. The session then moved to a question on the delay in appointments to the board of the Victims and Survivors Service despite a public competition completed two years earlier. The transcript provided ends during that exchange.